Moving From Downloads to Real Connections: Live Podcasting and Human ROI in the New Era with Alexandra Forsyth
#78

Moving From Downloads to Real Connections: Live Podcasting and Human ROI in the New Era with Alexandra Forsyth

Hey everybody, welcome to Poduty and the News for Monday,

July 20th, 2026. We're recording a day early today. We have a very

special guest calling in from the future, about 5 hours

ahead of us today. We're gonna be dreaming big, talking human ROI.

Take a chance on me. It's Alexandra Forsyth.

Alexandra, you know what time it is? It's

human ROI time. What time is it?

What time is it?

Oh, oh, it's time for Poduty

and the News.

Poduty and

the News, the only live news

podcast about podcasting from the

state. Poduty and the News. Poduty

and the News, the only

live news

Oh, the only live news podcast about podcasting from the stage.

Alexandra, welcome to the show. Hello, it's lovely to be here.

So glad to have you here. We, we, uh, we actually featured you on

this show about 2 months ago, and I reached out, said, hey, we're gonna

have this, and We couldn't get a— trying to get a comment and your take

on it, but the next best thing happened is you were able to

book a time to get on this show. So now our first article

today, we're going to be talking about your article. So I'm really

excited to have you here. And we've been talking about— I mentioned dream big and

human ROI. And I know you're the host of the Take a Chance on Me

podcast— Take a Chance on You podcast. I'm not an ABBA— I'm singing an

ABBA song. We were watching

What's the musical with ABBA in it? I can't think of it.

Mamma Mia. We literally watched Mamma Mia last night. So

Take a Chance on Me. But the podcast, Take a Chance on You.

Alexandra, tell us a little bit about that show. So if I had a

dime for every time somebody said take a chance on me.

But I— yeah, so Take a Chance on You, I launched last year

around February time. And it was through human connection. So I

know we're going to talk a lot about that today. But originally, I went networking

when I moved to London. I moved to London for a corporate job,

so I wasn't necessarily lonely too much, but I did find that I needed

to meet people. So, I would go to networking events, I would introduce

myself, but then I'm quite empathetic, so I tend to

listen to other people's stories and resonate that way. And

people would just tell me about their challenges of, one, loneliness and

community and not having enough people around them or

resources. And I just thought to myself, I think it's time to create a

platform where people can come on and share their stories, and

then we offer strategies out to listeners. We talk about wellbeing a lot now,

so burnout, stress, anxiety, and resilience

plays a key part in Take a Chance on You. And the names in the

title for the guests, it's taking a chance on themselves to give

themselves time to self-reflect. I don't think we do it enough. And then

human ROI and dream big has naturally compounding

effect off the podcast. Yeah. Amazing. I've been combing through your

website. There's a lot of videos, a TEDx talk. There's

appearances that you've been on other podcasts. You have to check it out. It's your

name with a hyphen in the middle, right? Yes.

alexandra-foresythe.com. I'll have the

link in the show notes. And go ahead, check it out, connect with

Alexandra, learn more about the podcast, learn more about Dream Big and

Human ROI. Are you ready to get

into our stories? I am.

Our first story today is something you're

very familiar with. This is from Podcasting Today, and the podcast

industry is rapidly evolving beyond traditional audio and video

formats, with more creators embracing live events,

hybrid experiences, and deeper audience engagement. In an

opinion piece for Podcasting Today, podcast host and leadership

strategist Alexandra Forsythe argues that success is shifting

away from simply maximizing downloads and ad impressions

towards creating meaningful in-person experiences.

Alexandra believes podcasting offers a unique form of human ROI

that can't be measured through analytics alone. As creators

build stronger communities through live events, brand

partnerships, authentic conversations, as AI continues to

transform media marketing, Alexandra sees human connection becoming

one of podcasting's greatest competitive advantages and

definitely a page right out of our playbook. I read this article

and I said, this is the future. This is the direction we're hand— hand,

you know, moving towards. And yeah, I'm so glad that we connected and I want

to, I've been waiting to hear, uh, your full take on, on the piece that

you wrote. Yeah. So I think, I mean, recently I

attended Creator Fest, which is a 2-day event here in London talking

about the creator economy, not specifically podcasting. But the—

we talked about vanity metrics and we talked about likes, comments, and shares

just on social media, on posts. And it is getting to the point with

brands when they want to partner with creators, the same with podcasters,

they are starting to learn that you have to look beyond, like I said,

the downloads, the likes, comments, and shares, and

look at the podcast host or look at the creator and their story.

How did they get to where they got to? What type of person are they?

Can you curate a campaign together? That's what woman make

for the most effective partnership and longevity in

terms of your career as well in the future. And it's the same with podcasting.

I mean, for me, because the podcast started in person at

events, and naturally it snowballed from there, I've always said to

myself, I do see my podcast going

back to the people in person, so in real life. That's

always been the mission and the goal for me. For other people, it

isn't. They're happy enough to be in the studio, or they just want the audio

element and possibly not even the video. But again, And then I went to the

podcast show here in London in May, and a key

theme was video, video and audio combined.

So the landscape is just vastly evolving, and podcasting hasn't

really been around that long, a couple of decades now, I would

say. But it's shifting, and we too have to shift

with the times and tune into our audiences. I think it's doing

what's right for you as a host, but then also looking at your community and

your demographic. What do the listeners want? Mm-hmm. Yep,

people can download MP3 files all day long and listen to the audio,

listen passively, maybe a morning commute, on a morning run, or,

you know, just in the background at work. But when you're able to get in

front of people, when you're making eye contact, when you're, you know,

in act— you know, interacting in the moment, you know, seeing the

face of the host, how they react to a question from the audience, or,

you know, how their brain thinks in real time, When you're face-to-face,

that is a 10, 100-time multiplier

of a human connection being in the room where the

podcast is live or watching the livestream unfold.

You can't get that from those vanity metrics that you're talking about. Yeah, you could

upload a TikTok that maybe gets 10,000, 20,000 views,

but what's the retention on that? Do people remember your brand? Yeah.

Did it drive podcast Other numbers, other

metrics, did it have any value to it compared to the

value of being in front of people? Maybe an audience of 10 or

20 people might actually be worth 10,000 or

20,000 downloads with the amount of connections you'll make in that, even in

that little tiny room. It's so much more important to be with

people. Well, I gave a talk at the podcast show and

there were around 40 to 50 people in the room. Pretty

much each and every person talked about loneliness in their independent

journey towards creating their podcast. And I would never have known

that had I not have been in that room. So, just by, I mean, we

were building a community in real time together, going back and forth,

talking, because I've gone through loneliness with the podcast. It's, I

don't think we talk enough about the backend and production and what actually goes

into building a podcast. Jeff, I'm sure you feel the same.

You're just wearing multiple hats and it is really hard. And I think because we,

Like I said, because we don't talk about it all the time, when reality

strikes and you think, oh my God, I've got to do X, Y, and Z.

So, I also think it's time that we start doing that a little bit more

and actually talking about the journey. I'm all for successes,

but the challenges is where people

build trust. Yeah, there's nothing replaces

it. And I'm apparently, I built a theater space, right, to have live podcasts. I

love this. I'm very bullish on live events and human

connection. We had some great events over the weekend. We had a

music act come through on Friday. We had a history

story, a podcast come through about a gentleman in the Great

Depression who hitchhiked across the United States, all

48 continental states on 48 cents. And it

was just a tremendous experience. They made a documentary about this gentleman.

His son was here who wrote a book. So to be in the room, to

hear that history from 100 years ago being told

live on stage, they had video clips from

reenactments, and you can't get that from just an

MP3 file. But to be here, that history came alive,

and it became a new experience. It's a new form of entertainment,

live podcasting. Yeah. It really breaks boundaries. It

breaks that fourth wall that you hear about on television where

All of a sudden they start talking to the audience. Well, that's literally happening when

you go see a live podcast. It's an experience unlike anything else.

Yeah. And I don't know, I mean,

Twitch and Roblox, for example, this has come into conversation. They

used to be for just gaming, but actually we're starting to see a shift

within apps and live streaming, just turning on your camera and

starting to have a conversation with the audience. in real time, what's to stop you

doing that with podcasting? Because when you're recording in the studio, you could always

just turn your camera on and have a conversation with your audience.

I think it's— the boundaries are being blurred, but in the best way.

What we've come to know podcasting as is— it's evolving, as I

said at the beginning, and it will continue to. Yes,

and speaking of making that connection, how about celebrating 3 years of

Media With a live podcast, a livestream, and a

subscriber party, kind of bringing all these things that we're talking about together.

Independent journalism outlet 404 Media is celebrating its 3rd

anniversary by hosting a 2-day event centered around its

community of paying subscribers. On September 3rd, the team

will record a live episode of the 404 Media podcast

at WNYC's Green Space, featuring discussions about

the future of independent journalism, AI data center resistance,

and science reporting. The event will also be livestreamed for

remote supporters. The celebration continues the following evening

with an anniversary party at Threes Brewing in Brooklyn,

where subscribers receive free or discounted admission based on their

membership levels. The event highlights how live

experiences can strengthen subscriber relationships while creating additional

value beyond digital content.

This is something I'm just in love with. You're having a

3-year anniversary tour or anniversary, and you're having a

2-day event with your subscribers, with your fans, with the

people who are supporting you. They're watching the videos, they're reading the

articles, they're downloading the content, and

now it's like the celebration. It's a reward for being

a loyal member. You get to meet the staff, you get to

see the authors who are writing the articles, the

videographers who are creating the content, the podcasters making the podcast.

Now it's all in one room for one big celebration. I love

that. And again, it goes— I think there's 2 points. My first point is

what I said about production in the backend, not talking about it enough, not seeing

the people behind the camera. So often you see the host and so often you

see the guest, but how often do you see, as you say, the videographer, the

person who's doing the lighting, the sound, or editing? I think it just, it

shouldn't take away the magic, and I said this time and time again, it should

elevate your story and your brand even further,

because people don't just imagine Geoff the host, or

Alexandra the host, or the guests, they imagine everybody else behind

the scenes, and again, it builds this camaraderie amongst,

amongst the brand, amongst the company, essentially, behind the whole thing. And

then, my second point is, I love the use of VIP. I've

always said, everybody wants to feel like a VIP, especially

your community, They want to feel like the most important person in the room. And

I mean, I think I can still remember the first person that started

subscribing and following the podcast. So it's, yeah,

you just— serendipity. You just got to keep people on their toes.

Yeah, even keep them guessing by location. Our next story

takes them— the Philadelphia Phillies podcast, they're going—

oh, what happened here? But also, Jeff, back on that

story, just one second. Yeah, yeah. Isn't it interesting how they're talking about

data centers? It's quite a hard-hitting topic

to be talking about at the event. Oh, we did.

But the— yeah, part of— they are— this media

company is very driven on human-created

articles, human-created content, and they are resisting data

centers and they're resisting AI. Yeah. Which I thought was a

great tie-in with human ROI. This media company

really wants to make sure that you know who's creating the content,

who's behind the content, and that's part of what they're

doing and what they're celebrating. Yeah, yeah, it makes sense.

We'll keep it moving. We'll go— here's a remote appearance.

You would see these 20 years ago with radio stations doing remote appearances,

but Uh, this one here, this is a Philadelphia Phillies

baseball team podcast. They go— they went to Ocean City

Boardwalk, so they're just right on the boardwalk. If you're watching the video, you can

see all the, the people walking back and forth behind them. It's a

pretty great experience. As, as the Philadelphia Phillies return from the MLB

All-Star break, The Phillies Show is taking its podcast

directly to the fans. On July 17th, host

Todd Zalecki of MLB.com Jim Salisbury

of NBC Sports Philadelphia and former Phillies general

manager Ruben Amaro Jr. recorded a live episode from

Manco and Manco Pizza on the Ocean City, New

Jersey boardwalk. The event featured guests

Charlie Manuel, who managed the Phillies to their

2008 World Championship, and former Phillies manager and

player Larry Bowa. Fans could attend the live recording in

person or watch and listen later across the

show's podcasting and streaming platforms.

And here's one, you got a live experience. So if you're a sports

fan and you're, you know, you're thinking, okay, I need to get away,

Philadelphia to Ocean City, I don't believe is too far away. Maybe it's an

hour drive. But hey, you're going to get out for the weekend, go grab a

slice of pizza at this pizza shop. So You're going to support a local business,

have a live event, meet some legends of the sports

team, and have this great conversation celebrating

baseball, celebrating the All-Star Game that just happened, and

pulling all that together with the fans, the hosts, the TV

personalities. They're all there really just sharing

their love of baseball. They're— and they're going where their audience is, right?

If you're going to have a show, And you're going to go to the beach

where people who love baseball are hanging out, they're on vacation. Here's a little

bonus for your vacation. Come see a live podcast about

baseball and have a night that you just couldn't recreate

through just a digital download. I think it's just

appreciation as well. As you say, taking it to the people,

making it easy for people to show up as well, and the fan

experience. We just finished the World Cup. We've been

talking about it in my workspace today. Obviously,

congratulations to Spain. But you do really, I mean, you

look at the stadium and it's filled with 80,000 fans. All of these

people just absolutely adore sports. So it

means a lot. And yeah, we can never forget that, especially in sports. I think

sports, out of all industries, the fan experience is the most

important part of it. Yeah, and it's something that really

expands beyond the game. And that's something I think this podcast is capitalizing on is,

That fandom doesn't just live on game day. It's 7

days a week, 24 hours a day. All year round. Yeah. And if you can

have a live event with your fans, you know, at a pizza shop, getting

pizza and beer and talking sports, you know, what a better night out.

And I think it also humanizes the experience. And we

talk about human beings a lot. I think

sometimes, and it's no fault of anybody's really, but when you're

watching a game on TV or on your phone or on social media,

sometimes it can feel quite unattainable. I'm never going to get to see my

favorite player. I can just see them through the screen. But actually being able to

see them in front of you humanizes the experience. And also, of course, you get

to ask your questions that you've been dying to ask them and get the answers.

And yeah, I love the element of humanizing experiences because

we're all human beings, so we should be connecting together.

Yeah. Where else can you be a part of the show? You can't, you can't

go on TV. You know, you're not going to be a call-in host on, on

most television shows in, in 2026. So to be in the

room where they're having the show about the thing that you love and you're

participating and you're, you're asking questions of the host to these

legends of the game, it's just, it just takes that

experience to the next level. It, it really builds on that fandom

and makes a connection that's so much deeper than just listening passively

on a radio or Or downloading a podcast episode. And I

also think surroundings plays a big

part in your career success, etc., who you surround

yourself with. So to be with top achievers, say in sports,

it will naturally make you want to elevate yourself. If you have dreams to be

in a similar position, it will help you get there. So I think

that's also huge. Yeah, and also huge,

guess who else is leaning in on live events, live

programming, Podcasts, and they're kind of,

you know, you think Netflix, you think, okay, the algorithm is going to bring me

a show, it's going to figure out what I like and suggest more of that.

But Netflix is also realizing, hey, people that listen to podcasts, they're

invested a lot more. They're listening and staying on, on, on

app a lot longer. Live programming, people watch a lot

longer when there's live programming, and the cost to produce these aren't

as much as those you know, billion-dollar mega franchises.

They're able to produce this at a relatively, you know, uh,

inexpensive— quick— the— as subscriber growth begins to

slow, Netflix is expanding beyond on-demand entertainment by

investing in live programming, podcasts, and AI. According

to CNBC, the company is seeing increased watch time as it

experiments with new formats that encourage audiences to engage

in different ways. Live, live events and podcast-related content

are becoming part of Netflix's broader strategy to keep viewers

connected to the platform, while AI is being used to improve the user

experience and support content discovery. The

shift reflects a growing trend across the media industry as

platforms look for new ways to increase engagement

beyond just traditional streaming.

I'm not surprised, to be honest. I, if anything, I'm

more surprised that Netflix have taken so long. I thought they would have been

hot on this a little bit sooner, earlier in 2026, but I guess

it's better late than never. I think—

too many thoughts. I, one thing that I love about

podcasting is that now, say with Netflix, for example, moving

slightly into the TV show programming,

arena is that you don't necessarily have to stick to a script. So, with

podcasting, we've always said to ourselves, okay, season 1, season 2,

season 3, maybe 15 to 20 episodes, and then we take a

break and we come back and then we're on to the next season. I do

think it's a bit more free flow. At least, that's what I'm doing at the

minute. I'm just putting out episodes. I'm going with the flow.

I still do one per week and then some short mini clips, but I don't

necessarily think to myself, right, I've got to end this season and then move on

to the next. I think, again, some of the trends we're seeing is

Churning out content the way you want to, what suits you.

Yeah, and it's a great play. You know, people have been

subscribing for years now, 10+ years subscribing services, so

they're, they're reaching a maturity. So there's only 2 more ways.

You can either find new subscribers, you can increase the rates every month,

or, you know, or you can really increase satisfaction to reduce

cancellation. So What you're seeing, I think, part of Netflix's strategy is

if we engage more people and give them current events,

current things that are happening, that are streaming live,

podcasts with fresh content, those are sticky

things that keep subscribers around. What are they doing? They're making

real-time connections, right? They're building an audience of loyal people

who want fresh and current and up-to-date information.

they're going to find that on these streaming platforms. And I think also

authentic content, so it's real

stories, lived experiences, that I feel like that's what people are really

looking for, not just within podcasting but TV,

media, entertainment, the creative industry. So I think the

outside world can be so uncertain at times, we want

to be able to come into a community and feel like it's

It's where we want to be. Speaking of

uncertain times, how about going to an open

mic and they have a podcast show show up? Bullseye with Jesse

Thorne took an unconventional approach to live podcasting by

surprising attendees at an open mic night at Lyric

Hyperion Theater in LA with a live interview

featuring comedian and writer Guy Branum, created as a

reward for supporters of Maximum Fun during its annual

membership drive. The event blended comedy, music, and

podcasting into a single experience. The interview was

recorded before a live audience, later released as a podcast

episode, and published on YouTube, extending the event

well beyond the people who attended in person. And I

should say, before I say though they just crashed the open mic, they did

make arrangements ahead of time. But it was a surprise. to

the audience that, okay, we're here for open mic night and all of a sudden

a celebrity shows up to do a live podcast. You know, it was an added

bonus and it seemed to be a great night and the audience was all about

it. I kind of love that and I think

people don't know what they don't know. So if you show up and you're recording

a podcast, people will enjoy it. I

don't know, I think I remember the early days when I was recording

Take a Chance on You, and I would invite guests on, and they'd never been

on a podcast before. By the end, they wanted to do more public speaking

and be on further podcasts because they enjoyed the experience so much. People don't

know what they don't know unless you put it in front of them. So, it's

the same with the open mic. They've taken it there, and people

resonate, they follow along, and before you know it, you've got new people within

your community. So, I think, don't stop

trying, and don't stop looking for new ways to reach

people and new audiences. 'Cause you're never done. I

think with podcasting, with TV, with entertainment, with

media, you're never done. Yeah. And the

live experience, again, the, this new form of entertainment that's, that's becoming

more and more prevalent in, in different areas. We see it at

conferences a lot where 10 years ago it would be a

panelist of, of 4 people, probably selected by the

sponsor of the conference who was just trying to

implant like some of their executives to get on, get some stage

time. But we're seeing that get replaced by live

podcasts from people within the industry who are experts in the industry,

livestreaming the industry. And you're getting that here. Here's a comedian who's gone on,

had a tremendous acting career, has written some great things, going

back to the roots of a comedy club where probably tested out some of this

material and telling the story, telling the history of, I

started on this stage, And I've grown to be a major

player in Hollywood. And for the people in the audience, that's what they're hoping.

They're hoping to make these connections at open mic, follow the

career, and see how they grow, see how they

develop over time. And you're getting that full story in one night.

You know, what an add-on. I think it's great. And also,

if I think about live activations and what I'm trying to do with Take a

Chance on You, As you say, at conferences, the landscape's changing.

Live podcasting is becoming a thing, but also just the dynamics

of events is also shifting. People want more. So,

with panel discussions, with keynotes, people want more strategy, more

action. So, I think podcasting is a fantastic way to kind of

infiltrate into these spaces. At least that's what I'm trying to do,

and I seem to be the only one really doing it on the live event

space here. in London, so it'd be good to see more of it.

And we have one last story remaining, and then again, live.

Live is such a big part of what I believe the future podcast—

like Alexandra said, we hear so much about audio and video. Video is kind of

the focus right now, but I think both of us agree that

beyond video are these connections, are these live

events, it's getting in front of people and performing your show

and This was a tour that came up as kind of a review, a

look back. And since launching in 2020, Trash Taste has

grown from a long-form anime podcast into a global

creator brand by combining video, audio, live events,

and social media. Hosted by Joey the Anime

Man, Garrent Gigguk,

and Connor CDawgVA, the show expanded from

studio recordings into sold-out theater performances and

convention appearances where the audience participation

and live interaction became central to the experience. Rather than

simply recording the podcast on a stage, the hosts built

live shows around games, Q&A sessions, and

improvisation, creating memorable moments that continue to

influence future podcast episodes. Their approach demonstrates how

niche podcasts can evolve into multi-platform

entertainment brands built around community and

shared experience. I love that. I love

their names as well. But I agree,

I think audio, video, live events, it's very much merging together,

and it's just always finding ways to reach new

people. Yeah, taking the show on the road and just

performing and We'll talk more and more. And, you know,

I think we— I've done maybe 75, 80 shows of this podcast.

Every week I'm coming to you with 6 new stories about live podcasting. So

this is happening all around the world. And, and I, I believe—

I don't remember where they were from, but they've done tours through the

States, through Australia, through Europe. They've been around

the world taking their podcast, this media asset that they created

they've taken it on tour. They've taken it from town to town, city

to city, and they're performing versions of it live in front

of an audience. And, and that's really where I think the future of

podcasting is going, is these immersive experiences,

these real-time events face to face with people. They

can't be beat as far as a night out or a form of entertainment.

I, I just don't think there's anything better, especially When you compare

the value, you know, a live podcast might be

$25 to $50 compared to a

concert that might be $300 for a ticket. So,

you know, they're very affordable, they're very approachable for most

people to get out there and really participate in events

like this. And I also think book tours,

for example, more people going on the road talking about their writing, you

can merge that with a podcast. If you have a podcast, you're writing a

book, and you publish the book, You can merge them together,

and oh my God, what a fantastic experience that would be for your core

community, because they're not only getting to see the host, but they're getting to see

the writer, etc., etc. And so, you can really

expand your portfolio with your community.

I think it's just being open-minded. I think with podcasting now, it's just

remaining open-minded. Live events are the future. I think it's a lot to do with

feeling and emotion. People want to feel something,

and Human touch, connection. We said that

throughout. Can't be understated. Yeah.

And like you're mentioning, a couple of the events that we covered tonight talked about

recording that episode to have an asset for later release.

They would release it on video, they'd release it as a podcast. So a

book tour is a great example. You go around, go to different bookstores, do some

Q&A. Now you have a podcast, you have a video episode.

Yeah, absolutely. I think it's, yeah, like I said, people

just need to remain a little bit more open-minded. I think because

I also do a lot of public speaking, and I have done for years, so

podcasting wasn't my first rodeo in front of an audience. I've been

travelling, talking to different people, so podcasting was, to be honest,

naturally an extension of what I was already doing. But that's another prime

example. If you're doing public speaking, depending what industry, you can merge

the two together. It shouldn't, It shouldn't feel hard

to do any of these things. Live events shouldn't feel hard. It should feel

like a natural progression. Yeah,

and I hope we continue to stay in touch. I hope to continue following

more and hearing more opinion pieces about the future, which

is really, you know, I can't stress enough that

these face-to-face human connection, even livestream, you

know, in-person events, These are the future things that a

lot of independent creators, a lot of independent media companies,

that's what they're building towards. They know that the value is face-to-face

and they want to connect. And I just, I see this growing so much in

the next 3 to 5 years. Gosh, this time next year, I

think, what will we be saying in the summer of 2027? Who knows?

I can't wait. I can't wait to see you then. And the last thing we

do before we say goodbye is I'd like to turn the stage over to you

one last time, Alexandra. You can plug, promote, talk

about anything, anything you'd like. I'm

terrible at this. I'm terrible. I don't even do it on my own. I'm

awful, but okay. Okay. The floor is yours.

It's been an absolute pleasure to be here talking to Jeff about all things live

events. As I say, I'm the host of Take a Chance on You,

a UK-based podcast. I'm based in London, but we're

transatlantic. So we've had guests from the US, from different parts of

Europe, and I'd love to have you as part of this

community. You can find us on all social media channels. You can

follow on Spotify, Apple, and YouTube. You can listen to the audio, you can

watch the video. We are experimenting with live

activations, and I look forward to speaking to

many of you soon. Please don't hesitate, hesitate to get in touch, and thank you

very much. Well, thank you. Thank you. I got one

last question for you. Do you remember

what time it was? Human ROI time.